The Truth about Dogs Repository

A curated, evidence-led repository on humane, force-free dog training — peer-reviewed studies, official positions, and expert voices, with sources you can check.

← Back to archive
Official position2024

Reward-based methods are more effective and less likely to backfire

BSAVA recommends positive reinforcement and outlines the welfare risks and behavioural fallout associated with aversive methods, tying the position directly to UK legislation and codes of practice.

Reward-based methods of training are both more effective and less likely to have undesired consequences.

Source details

Source

BSAVA Position Statement: Aversive Training Methods

BSAVA Scientific Committee

British Small Animal Veterinary Association

Evidence level

Official position

Credibility

Last reviewed

May 30, 2026

Why we included it

Current professional position used to support UK e-collar legislation.

WelfareE-collarsProng collars